I would choose...
Amnesia Pill: Harry Potter books
Sacrifice Pill: Augustus Waters from TFIOS
Love Pill: Leo Valdez from Percy Jackson or Steve Rogers from Marvel or Percy Jackson from Percy Jackson or Liam Stewart from the Darkest Minds or Spencer Reid from Criminal Minds.
Life Pill: Fred and George from Harry Potter
Travel Pill: Hogwarts, duh.
Body Pill: Any Hogwarts student or Camp Half-Blood kid.